We Need Less Wolverine

Wolverine Fail

Ok, ok, settle down. Read the article first. Then there’s a poll at the bottom so you can have your say. But seriously, we need less Wolverine.

Wolverine angry

“Umm…can someone else tell him?”

This notion has come to the fore once again with the plot details of the upcoming X-Men: Days of Future Past film. It’s based on one of Chris Claremont’s popular story that revolved around Shadowcat falling through time and seeing a bleak vision of the future. The movie trailer followed the same premise…except Wolverine travels through time instead of Shadowcat.

Let’s wind it back. When the X-Men started out it was comprised of five teenagers who were codenamed Cyclops, Marvel Girl, Iceman, Beast and Angel. They were lead by Professor X, though he was killed off early in the piece to focus on the young characters (as with many X-Men this was a mild case of death that quickly resolved itself). The title was not a big hit and before long was facing the axe. In order to breath new life into the ensemble a new group of international teens were added – Storm, Nightcrawler, Colossus, Sunspot, Thunderbird.

And Wolverine.

Giant Size X-Men

Wolverine, or Logan, was an unusual addition to the line-up. He was one of the older new members of the team and had been an established character in the Marvel universe. He was introduced as a villain for the Hulk but was quickly included in X-Men. Rather than dealing with teenage issues he was a vicious, angry character with a dark past. Unsurprisingly he was an instant hit.

It’s only natural that he would become a prominent feature of the comics. The fans loved him so the writers delivered. No doubt they enjoyed writing the darker, dangerous character more than the stand-up Cyclops or the sassy Iceman. Having a mysterious past was a huge boon for the character, becoming the source of much speculation and theories.


Although Wolverine was given his one solo title to tell of his adventures he was still central to almost every X-Men story. When Psylocke travelled to Japan to seek her origins Wolverine tagged along because he had his own Japan story. When Gambit reconnected with his family of thieves Wolverine was with him. The majority of new enemies who the X-Men encountered were nursing a grudge against Wolverine.

Everything got even more ridiculous with some of the reboots, such as Ultimate X-Men where a number of previously un-Wolverine’d stories were rewritten to include him. Originally Cable was introduced as the son of Cyclops and Phoenix travelled from the future. Now he was Wolverine. When you look at the trade paperback covers you’d be forgiven for thinking he was the only character.

Ultimate X-Men 1Ultimate X-Men 2Ultimate X-Men 3Ultimate X-Men 4

It isn’t until the eighth volume that any of the other characters appear on the cover.

The argument that the writers are simply giving the readers what they want doesn’t stretch to rewriting half the characters to fit in Wolverine. This is especially true when you look at the Wolverine solo titles already being published, not to mention his inclusion in other major titles such as The Avengers and Spider-Man. The odd cameo every now and then is fine but one character dominating every story under the Marvel umbrella defeats the purpose of having such a diverse range of characters. The X-Men so frequently become side-characters to the Wolverine story that they may as well rename the comic Wolverine and the X-Men.

Wolverine and the X-Men

Oh. Never mind.

Being a massive Batman fan I am not blind to there being a similar phenomenon with the Dark Knight himself. Among the 52 new titles in the relaunch we have BatmanBatgirl, Batman & Robin, Batman: The Dark Knight, Batwing, Batwoman, Detective Comics, Catwoman, Nightwing, Red Hood and the Outlaws and the discontinued Batman Incorporated. That’s not even including other titles he crops up in like Justice League. I suspect the difference here is that Batman isn’t taking the spotlight in ensemble casts, or cameoing in any title that holds still long enough. He’s just the centre of a wide network of characters who branch out on their own, and the different titles have their own tone and style. Wolverine is just Wolverine, and across the various reboots he has managed to come out intact. Marvel knew they were on to a good thing with the grizzled, deadly and mysterious character so they just spread him across their entire industry like hairy jam.

Ultimately the problem comes down to there being to much. If you take something else that is awesome, such as a Twix bar, and include with every meal regardless of it’s suitability it is only natural that people will eventually become tired of it. They my even come to resent it, and want to spend more time with Malteasers, simply because they want to experience something different. That is what Marvel is risking doing here. By forcing the reader to include Wolverine in all of their stories and team-ups they are going to breed a generation of comic readers and movie goers who are resentful of him being in the spotlight when there are equally interesting characters waiting to tell their stories.

So what should be done? Keep the Canuk where he’s strongest. Keep him in the X-Men because every team needs someone who will ruffle the feathers. But let him merge into the collage of characters. It would make the stories about him stand out more. Save his biggest moments and real character development for his solo line where his biggest fans will appreciate it. Wolverine is a staple of the Marvel universe, but balancing that entire universe on the one character is an outright bad idea. It’s all about balance the elements of your product.


Like this.

Now I’m going to buy a Twix.


An example balancing the elements.

9 Responses to “We Need Less Wolverine”
  1. Desperado316 says:

    I think that the X-Men Franchise is milking Wolverine, simply because he’s the most popular character. I for one would have preferred to see Shadow-Cat slip through time as it should be according to the original story. I think with the Wolverine Movies, we get to see enough of Jackman and Logan so this should be a change. I liked First Class because firstly the plot was great and secondly the cast was different. We get to see different faces. I’m disappointed to know the main focus of yet another X-Men movie is Wolverine.

    Don’t get me wrong… He’s still my second favourite X-Men Character after Gambit but I’m getting tired of seeing him all the time.


    • gfunk101 says:

      I’d Like to see Taylor kitsch get another crack at Gambit – he’s a good actor and it’s just sad that his first two big features were abject failures.


    • Indeed. Wolverine is also my second favorite. I like Nightcrawler. Gambit comes third. Or second. Depending on the day.


  2. ari826 says:

    Call me naïve, but when I think of the X-Men, the first people that come to mind is Phoenix, Professor X and Magneto… Wolverine was always just part of the team… and the X-Men origins movies have no shame, they are ruining these stories to the new, very impressionable generation smh


    • Why is it always about the new generation? Every generation seems to have some sort of animosity toward the next. xDIf you’re talking about the ones who are currently children, then yes. Definitely. As they are indeed children. It all comes down to money and marketing. Marvel was going down the drain, the Wolverine stories basically bailed them out, and there you have it. It makes a lot of money.

      I always hated Pheonix. And Scott friggin Summers. When I was younger, I always thought of Nightcrawler, Storm, Shadowcat, Prof X and Magneto. Totally biased towards my favorites. Wolverine was always a side character for me until the movies came out.


      • gfunk101 says:

        I started reading X-Men during the prime time of Wolverine centered stories, the Jim Lee/Chris Claremont team up.


      • Ah. I have always been huge on cartoons, so I watched various x-men cartoons before I read the comics. There are so many, I didn’t know where to start. There is a shift from the actual team to focusing on wolverine in the cartoons. One of the more recent cartoons uses a lot of the days of future past story line and focuses heavily on wolverine. But every character/small group of characters got their own story line, so it worked.

        Anywho, after the cartoons and a couple of movies I finally sat down and read weapon x. One of my favorites.


  3. sabinafelice says:

    Much as I love Wolverine, I think there’s way too much of him. Isn’t he in every Marvel superteam EVER? Not to mention more movies than I thought logically possible. Cut down on this guy’s appearances and give some more attention to the lesser-known X-Men, preferably those in minority groups.


  4. Noccie says:

    I think my favorite line in the article was “…so they just spread him across their entire industry like hairy jam.” Thank you for speaking out in such an informed way about how they’ve kit bashed the new X-Men movie. :) Plus it would have been nice to see the original story with a central female character.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: