Movie Review: ‘Wild Horse Nine’


Plot: Shortly before the 1973 Chilean coup d’etat, CIA operatives Chris (John Malkovich) and Lee (Sam Rockwell) vacation to Easter Island. The trip is at the behest of Chri,s who is suffering from terminal cancer and progressive dementia. Although a friend, colleague, and protégé of Chris, Lee finds his morphine addiction and unhinged behavior increasingly annoying. With little time remaining and much to the consternation of bureau chief MJ (Steve Buscemi), Chris has begun to record a memoir concerning his various CIA career highlights. These include such noted 20th century events such as the Bay of Pigs Invasion, the assassination of Patrice Lumumba, and the assassination of JFK. Despite becoming increasingly paranoid and clearly filled with regrets, Chis is determined to enjoy the last days of his life, even befriending two young Chilean vacationers, Monica (Mariana di Girolamo) and Alicia (Alin Salas). Under increasing pressure from MJ to take out Chris, Lee must decide the best course of action before time runs out—possibly for both of them.

Review: If you asked me point blank who I believed the most underrated director of the last 20 years is, I would answer writer/director Martin McDonagh without a moment’s hesitation. From In Bruges, to Seven Psychopaths, to The Banshees of Inisherin, the man has yet to make a bad film. I’m thrilled to say that with McDonagh’s latest that streak continues, as Wild Horse Nine is another certified banger from the Irish auteur.

Darkly comedic and laugh out loud funny, with some impeccable acting performances and dialogue that crackles like a roaring fire on a County Down moor, Wild Horse Nine is quite possibly the best comedy of the year.

While there are many elements that constitute a phenomenal film, for me the foundation will always be the script, and Wild Horse Nine is built on a great one. I was actually impressed and delighted that Wild Horse Nine unfolds like a play, with Chris and Lee being the primary two characters occupying the majority of the screentime. That probably shouldn’t shock me because in addition to being a screenwriter and director, McDonagh is a noted playwright. That tactic doesn’t always translate well to film, but it works perfectly for Wild Horse Nine. The dialogue (especially between Lee and Chris) often feels like a verbal tennis match, replete with witticisms that had me cracking up. Chris’ rumination about whether or not dinosaurs and cancer (yes cancer) are in heaven is one of the quirkiest, funniest, weirdly relatable things I’ve heard all year. The rest of the film script is in the same vein.

Yet McDonagh’s latest tale doesn’t merely rely on pithy quips. As a director, McDonagh is a master at extracting and showcasing humanity among the darkly comedic. Although Lee often finds Chris’s shenanigans and exploits borderline insufferable, you never doubt that they are best friends and that Lee possesses the utmost respect for his mentor. There are some profoundly heavy moments in this film that affected me on an emotional level. One such incident is when Chris warns Monica not to return to Chile because of what’s about to take place, something he goes into in dark detail. You can see Monica’s disillusionment happening in real time. The closing scene between Chris and Lee also hits the like a George Foreman punch to the solar plexus. The tone of Wild Horse Nine is a delicate balancing act of dark humor and human drama, but thankfully McDonagh is up to the task. I have no doubt that once again he will receive Oscar nominations for writing and directing. While I don’t think he’ll win the latter, walking away with the gold for the former is almost a guarantee.

In a cinema age where it feels like every damn thing is shot in front of a blue screen, it’s nice to see movies still shot on location. Long-time cinematographer Ben Davis (who’s been working with McDonagh since 2012’s Seven Psychopaths) shoots Wild Horse Nine with a verve and vigor that fully displays beautiful of Easter Island. There’s a pervasive sense of history about the island that bleeds into the film and dovetails nicely with an intimate story about male friendship, regret, and the permanence of death. Davis’s work is complemented by a playful and occasionally melancholic score from Carter Burwell.

Although Wild Horse Nine sports an excellent script, masterful direction, and scintillating cinematography, the heart and soul of the film belong to its two main leads—Sam Rockwell’s Lee and John Malkovich’s Chris. Lee is the perfect foil to Chris, and Rockwell provides his best performance arguably since Three Billboards. Rockwell’s chemistry with Malkovich is palpable. The facial reactions Rockwell exhibits to some of the things Malkovich’s Chris says and does had me hollowing with laughter. Yet Rockwell also brings a real pathos to Lee. Lee is protective of Chris and, Chris’ impending death is clearly weighing on Lee, even if he doesn’t always overtly show it. Additionally, despite never being in the same room together, some of the best scenes involve Lee talking with his wife Marge, played brilliantly by Parker Posey. Ditto, Rockwell’s interactions with the always solid Steve Buscemi, who plays MJ like the biggest bureaucratic dick you can imagine, all to great effect.

Yet, it is John Malkovich’s performance as Chris that really impresses. This is a career best performance for Malkovich, and as the current consensus front-runner, it may very well garner him his first Best Actor win at the next Academy Awards. Malkovich’s Chris is equal parts hysterical, annoying, endearing, despicable, and surprisingly soulful. Although facing his own death, Chris never comes off scared or maudlin. If anything, he’s regretful and believes he “should’ve hung out with more horses.” I know that last probably makes no sense inside of a film review but trust me it hits with the power of Mack truck inside the context of the film. By the end of the movie you feel genuine sympathy for Chris if not necessarily empathy.  Aside from Rocky in Project Hail Mary, Malkovich’s Chris may be the most memorable movie character I’ve seen this year.

With rapier wit, exquisite cinematography, stellar direction, and with a powerhouse performance from John Malkovich, Wild Horse Nine once again proves why Martin McDonagh is one of the best working today.

Damn, I loved this movie.

My rating system:

1 God Awful Blind Yourself With Acid Bad

2 Straight Garbage

3 Bad

4 Sub Par

5 Average

6 Ok

7 Good

8 Great

9 Excellent

10 A Must See

Masterpiece

Wild Horse Nine: 9/10

My Physical Media Barometer System:

Day One Purchase

Wait for a sale

Accept as a gift

Burn every copy you find

Wild Horse Nine: Day One Purchase